Why Twitter isn’t representative of teaching but Secret Teacher isn’t either

Standard

I often think that Twitter is not a true reflection of all teachers who work in all types of school. I’ve never seen any tweets saying ‘Today I had a chair thrown at me by a year 9’ or ‘I broke up a fight with two year 11 boys’.

Instead I see ‘Look at the fantastic work my year 7 group did today’ or ‘Congrats to our football team for winning their game’.

Whilst there are debates, maybe arguments and some nastiness amongst individuals on Twitter,  the realities of all schools are not represented. Where are those teachers who are going through hell?

Of course there are huge issues with people telling the truth about their school, especially if their Twitter account is identified directly to them. I’m not arguing that people should put themselves, the school and/or the children at risk by posting tweets with potentially problematic issues however I’m concerned about how those that are having tough times in school share those experiences, and possibly ask for advice.

Twitter can be a helpful, caring, sharing community but it has boundaries on what people ‘can’ ask about. Should it also be a place where people with serious difficulties can share? Or maybe those on Twitter haven’t experienced this kind of school & can’t empathise or offer advice? Is it really only partially representative of the teaching community?

This is why I get frustrated when people criticise The Guardian’s ‘Secret Teacher’ for seeming to always be negative and painting an unbalanced image of teaching. These people forget that whilst Twitter is generally  full of positivity there are colleagues around the country that are having a nightmare;a truly challenging and potentially damaging time.

Where is their voice? Where can they ‘safely’ say what is happening to them? Just because it isn’t all sparkly & may make people question the profession once in a while, should we stop it and pretend it doesn’t exist?

Secret teacher is one way of giving these teachers in challenging circumstances a voice.

So whilst neither provides a balanced view, at least both give a voice to teachers in their current situation. I’m worried there are many teachers out there struggling, who can’t take advantage of the Twitter community and the catharsis of blogging due to fear of judgement or worse.

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Why Twitter isn’t representative of teaching but Secret Teacher isn’t either

  1. It’s a very interesting question. Twitter didn’t exist when I worked in a school like the one you are talking about. However, even if it had I don’t think I would have posted about my experiences on social media. There are a few reasons for this – firstly, I would have been too busy just running to stand still to even think about using Twitter, secondly, it feels very vulnerable to be in that situation, so you don’t necessarily want to share that experience, and I suppose thirdly (as you identify) you would need to do it anonymously because of all the issues around the school being identifiable.

  2. Pingback: Reality Check | fractionfanatic

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s